Problems in a Haken (Dispatch) Job in Japan: How to Solve Them (2026)
Most problems in a haken (派遣, dispatch) job in Japan come from four questions that nobody answered clearly at the start: who your employer is, why your pay looks lower than expected, whether the pension you pay is worth it, and what happens at contract renewal. When these are left unclear, small doubts grow into distrust between engineers, the agency and the client company. This guide gives the rule behind each question and a simple way to get a clear answer.
The guide is written for engineers employed by a dispatch agency and working at a client company in Japan. Rules are as of November 2026, based on the Labour Standards Act, the Worker Dispatch Act, the Labour Contract Act and sources from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) and the Japan Pension Service. This is general information, not legal advice. For your own case, ask your agency in writing first, and then the public offices listed at the end.
Key takeaways
In dispatch work, the agency is your employer. It pays you, enrols you in social insurance and decides contract renewal. The client company directs your daily work.
Working on a public holiday is not automatically overtime. A premium is required by law only beyond 8 hours a day or 40 hours a week, or for work on your legal day off.
Pay deductions for breaks and for hours not worked are usually rule-based. Ask for the rule in writing and check it against your contract.
Japanese pension contributions are not lost: you can claim a lump-sum withdrawal when you leave Japan, or keep the periods for a future pension. Check the Japan–India social security agreement before you decide.
You cannot lawfully be treated badly for asking questions or for reporting a legal violation to the authorities. Renewal decisions must follow criteria written in your contract.
Why do problems happen in haken (dispatch) jobs in Japan?
Problems in dispatch jobs usually happen because three parties are involved and each one explains only part of the picture. You talk every day with the client company's team, but your contract, salary and social insurance are with the agency. When a question about pay or renewal goes to the wrong party, or is answered only by word of mouth, different people hear different things.
Question | Who decides | Who you should ask |
|---|---|---|
My salary, overtime pay, deductions | Agency (your employer) | Agency |
Social insurance and pension | Agency (enrols you and pays the employer's share) | Agency |
Contract renewal | Agency, based on the dispatch contract with the client and the criteria in your employment contract | Agency |
Daily tasks, team rules, working hours on site | Client company, within the dispatch contract | Your supervisor at the client |
Harassment or safety at the workplace | Both: the client manages the site, the agency must respond to your complaint | Either; both must act |
By law, the agency must appoint a dispatch-source manager (派遣元責任者 hakenmoto sekininsha) and the client must appoint a dispatch-destination manager (派遣先責任者 hakensaki sekininsha). One of their jobs is to handle complaints from dispatched workers. Ask your agency who these people are on your first day. For the basics of the three-party system, see haken (dispatch) work explained.
Who is my employer in a dispatch job, the agency or the client?
In a dispatch job, the dispatch agency is your employer, not the client company where you work. The agency signs your employment contract, pays your salary, withholds tax, enrols you in social insurance, and is responsible for your working conditions. The client company gives you daily work instructions.
This matters in two ways:
Your rights come from your employment contract with the agency. If something in your pay or contract is unclear, the agency must explain it. The client usually cannot change your salary.
"The agency is your employer" is a fact, not a threat. It does not mean the agency can end your contract freely. Ending or not renewing a contract must follow the law and the criteria written in your contract (see below).
If you plan to work directly for the client company later, read the rules in how to change jobs in Japan as a foreigner and talk to your agency early. Doing it openly avoids conflict on all sides.
Why didn't I get overtime pay for working on a public holiday in Japan?
You did not get an overtime premium for working on a public holiday because, in Japanese law, a national holiday is not automatically a "legal day off". The law requires a premium only for work beyond 8 hours a day or 40 hours a week (at least 25% extra), and for work on the legal day off (法定休日 hōtei kyūjitsu), which is at least 1 day a week (at least 35% extra). These rules are in the Labour Standards Act, Articles 32, 35 and 37, and the premium rates are set by Cabinet Order No. 5 of 1994 (Japanese).
Here is a common example. A national holiday falls on Monday, and you work Monday to Friday, 8 hours each day.
Day | Hours worked | Weekly total | Premium required by law? |
|---|---|---|---|
Monday (public holiday) | 8 | 8 | No — within 8 h/day and 40 h/week |
Tuesday | 8 | 16 | No |
Wednesday | 8 | 24 | No |
Thursday | 8 | 32 | No |
Friday | 8 | 40 | No — exactly 40 h |
Saturday (if you also work) | 8 | 48 | Yes — 8 h of overtime at 25%+ |
Sunday (if it is your legal day off) | 8 | — | Yes — legal day-off work at 35%+ |
You are paid for all 40 hours. What you do not get is an extra premium, because the week stayed within 40 hours. Many companies pay a holiday allowance under their own work rules (就業規則 shūgyō kisoku), so check your contract and the agency's work rules. If they promise a holiday premium, it must be paid.
For more on overtime caps and rates, see overtime rules in Japan for engineers.
Why were hours deducted from my salary in Japan?
Hours are deducted from a salary in Japan for two common reasons: unpaid break time, and hours you were scheduled but did not work. Both are normal when they follow a written rule. Problems start when nobody showed you the rule.
Deduction | What the law says | What to check |
|---|---|---|
Break time | Your employer must give at least 45 minutes of break if you work more than 6 hours, and at least 1 hour if you work more than 8 hours (Labour Standards Act, Article 34). Breaks are unpaid. | How long your break is and when it starts to apply. A company may give a longer break than the minimum. |
Hours not worked | In principle, time you did not work is not paid ("no work, no pay"), unless your contract says otherwise. | Arriving late or leaving early under a fixed schedule is usually deducted. Flextime works differently. |
Social insurance and tax | Health insurance, pension, employment insurance and income tax are withheld every month. |
Example: your schedule is 8:30 to 17:30 with a 1-hour break, which is 8 paid hours. If you work 9:30 to 17:00, you were present 7.5 hours; after the 1-hour break, you worked 6.5 hours, so 1.5 hours are deducted. If the rule says no break is deducted for days under 6 hours, a 5-hour day has no break deduction.
Ask your agency for a line-by-line explanation of one payslip in writing. Once you understand one month, you can check every month yourself.
Is it worth paying Japanese pension as a foreign engineer?
Paying into Japan's Employees' Pension (厚生年金 kōsei nenkin) is required for employees, and the money is not lost even if you leave Japan. You have two main options when you leave:
Option | How it works | Good for |
|---|---|---|
Lump-sum withdrawal (脱退一時金 dattai ichijikin) | Claim within 2 years after you no longer have an address in Japan. As of November 2026, it counts up to 60 months (5 years) of contributions. 20.42% income tax is withheld, which may be refundable (Japan Pension Service). | People who are sure they will not come back to work in Japan |
Keep your pension periods | Your periods stay on record. If you return to Japan later, they continue to count. | People who may return, or who are close to 10 years |
Use a social security agreement | Japan and India have a social security agreement (in force since October 2016) that lets periods in both countries be added together for pension eligibility (Japan Pension Service). | Indian nationals who may work in both countries |
The important trade-off: once you take the lump-sum withdrawal, all your Japanese pension periods are erased, including for the agreement. Decide only after checking your own case. Full details are in the pension lump-sum withdrawal guide, and the whole system is explained in social insurance in Japan explained.
Health insurance is also valuable while you are in Japan: it pays 70% of medical costs and gives cash support if you cannot work because of illness. Ask your agency to show you both what you pay and what the employer pays on top, so you can see the full value.
Can my agency refuse to renew my contract because I asked questions?
No. Asking questions about your pay or contract is not a lawful reason to end or not renew your contract, and the law protects workers who report legal violations. A worker who reports a violation of the Labour Standards Act to the Labour Standards Inspection Office must not be dismissed or treated badly for it (Labour Standards Act, Article 104). The Worker Dispatch Act gives dispatched workers the same protection when they report violations to the MHLW (Worker Dispatch Act, Article 49-3, Japanese).
Renewal of a fixed-term contract is not automatic, but it is not unlimited freedom for the employer either:
Rule | What it means for you |
|---|---|
Renewal criteria must be in writing | Since April 2024, employers must state in writing whether the contract can be renewed, the criteria for renewal, and any cap on the number of renewals or total years (MHLW, Japanese). |
Limits on non-renewal | If your contract has been renewed many times, or you have a reasonable expectation of renewal, non-renewal without an objectively reasonable reason may be invalid (Labour Contract Act, Article 19, Japanese). |
Conduct can be a criterion | A contract may say that serious breaches of work rules affect renewal. This must be written and applied fairly, not used as a general warning. |
If someone tells you about renewal or dismissal only verbally, ask for it in writing. Clear, written criteria protect you and also stop rumours inside a team.
How do I raise a problem with my dispatch agency in Japan?
The fastest way to solve a problem with your dispatch agency is to put the question in writing, ask for a written answer with the rule behind it, and keep a record. Group complaints in a chat often spread faster than the facts. A short written question gets a clear answer.
Write down the facts. Date, payslip month, hours, the amount you expected and the amount you received.
Send it to the right person. Pay and contract questions go to the agency (your dispatch-source manager), not to your supervisor at the client.
Ask for the rule. "Which clause of my contract or the work rules is this based on?" Ask for an answer in English if you need it.
Ask for a meeting if you still disagree. Bring the payslip and contract. Ask for a short written summary after the meeting.
Go to a public office if the problem is not solved. You can do this at any time, and you cannot lawfully be punished for it.
Public office | What it handles |
|---|---|
Labour Standards Inspection Office (労働基準監督署) | Unpaid wages, overtime pay, working hours, breaks |
Prefectural Labour Bureau (労働局), General Labour Consultation Corner | Dispatch rules, contract renewal, harassment, mediation between you and your employer |
Consultation in English and other languages | |
Pension records, lump-sum withdrawal, social security agreements |
What should I check before signing a dispatch contract in Japan?
Before signing a dispatch contract in Japan, check that the answers to the most common future problems are already in writing. Most of the problems in this guide can be prevented with these questions:
Ask before signing | Why it prevents problems later |
|---|---|
Who is my employer, and who is my contact for pay questions? | You know where to go from day one |
What are my scheduled hours, break rules and legal day off? | Holiday and deduction questions are answered in advance |
Are national holidays working days? Is there a holiday allowance? | No surprise at the first holiday |
What is deducted from my pay (social insurance, tax, anything else)? | You can check your first payslip |
What are the renewal criteria and any cap? | Renewal is predictable, not a rumour |
Who are the dispatch-source and dispatch-destination managers? | You know who handles complaints |
The full checklist is in employment contract in Japan: checklist.
FAQ
Q. Who is responsible if I have a problem in a haken job in Japan?
Your dispatch agency is responsible for your pay, contract, social insurance and renewal, because it is your employer. The client company is responsible for daily instructions and the workplace. For harassment or safety problems, both must respond.
Q. Do I get overtime pay for working on a national holiday in Japan?
Not automatically. A legal premium is required only for hours beyond 8 a day or 40 a week (at least 25% extra), or for work on your legal day off (at least 35% extra). Your company's work rules may promise more, so check them.
Q. Why is my salary lower than expected in my dispatch job?
Usually because of social insurance and tax withholding, unpaid break time, or hours not worked. Ask your agency for a written, line-by-line explanation of one payslip and the rules behind each deduction.
Q. Can a dispatch agency fire me for complaining?
No. Asking about your pay or contract is not a lawful reason for dismissal or non-renewal. Reporting legal violations to the Labour Standards Inspection Office or the MHLW is protected by law.
Q. Is Japanese pension a waste of money for foreigners?
No. You can claim a lump-sum withdrawal after leaving Japan (up to 60 months counted as of November 2026), or keep your pension periods. Indian nationals should also check the Japan–India social security agreement before claiming.
Q. Is a dispatch contract renewal guaranteed in Japan?
No. But the renewal criteria must be in writing, and if you have a reasonable expectation of renewal, non-renewal needs an objectively reasonable reason under the Labour Contract Act.
Q. Where can foreign workers get free labour advice in Japan?
At the Labour Standards Inspection Office, the Labour Consultation Corner of the Prefectural Labour Bureau, and the MHLW consultation line for foreign workers, which supports English.
Official sources
All legal rules in this guide are taken from official Japanese government sources (checked November 2026):
Labour Standards Act (Articles 32, 34, 35, 37, 104), English translation: Japanese Law Translation, Ministry of Justice
Minimum premium rates for overtime and legal day-off work (25% / 35%): Cabinet Order No. 5 of 1994, e-Gov (Japanese)
Worker Dispatch Act (Articles 36, 41, 49-3): e-Gov Law Search (Japanese)
Labour Contract Act (Article 19): e-Gov Law Search (Japanese)
April 2024 rules on stating renewal criteria: MHLW (Japanese)
Pension lump-sum withdrawal: Japan Pension Service (English) / Japanese
Japan–India Social Security Agreement: Japan Pension Service
Labour consultation offices: General Labour Consultation Corners, MHLW / Consultation for foreign workers, MHLW
This guide explains general rules. Your contract and the agency's work rules decide the details, so always check them for your own case.
Looking for a dispatch job with clear conditions?
AGG Careers lists engineering jobs in Japan where AGG is your employer. Every job card shows the field, Japanese level and who can apply. See open jobs, then apply. AGG replies by email within 3 business days.


